Supercritical CO2 Solubility

Solubilité du CO2 supercritique.

Supercritical CO2 extraction process depends by CO2 solubility. ”. A supercritical fluid is any compound at a temperature and pressure above its Critical Point. It can diffuse through solids like a gas, and it can dissolve materials like a liquid.

For any pure compound, there is a transition state called “critical state”: for temperatures below the critical temperature Tc, two phases – liquid and vapor – coexist; for temperature above Tc, there is only one phase: supercritical fluid. Solubility is a function of pressure and temperature:

  • Solubility Increases with increasing pressure at constant temperature.
  • Solubility may increase, or decrease, when temperatures are raised at constant pressure.

Solubility is related to density. Higher density, higher solubility. This is true from the theoretical point of view, but when applied to singular compoundwe may see different results, as shown in the graph alongside.

CO2 solubility for “simple” systems and relatively low solubility, the empirical correlation proposed by Chrastil can be used to interpret experimental results with a good reliability without any complicated calculations :

C = density^k × exp [a/T + b]

where C is the solute concentration, a, b and k empirical constants ; this correlation shows the extreme dependence of the solubility to the fluid specific gravity. It also shows that  :

  • Solubility increases with density (or pressure) at constant temperature ;
  • Solubility may increase or decrease when temperature is raised at constant pressure.

In all cases, the solubility dramatically decreases when the fluid is depressurized at constant temperature below its critical pressure, with solubility variation of several orders of magnitude. This is the basis of most SCF processes : SCF are used as solvents in the supercritical fluid region to selectively extract some compound(s) before being depressurized to cause the solute(s) precipitation permitting the fluid-solute separation.

Enhanced Solvent Extraction (ESE)

Extraction améliorée par solvants (EAS).

Supercritical Carbon dioxide is a great solvent for apolar substances. Our compressed water and carbon dioxide extraction system allows the extraction of polar substances. The action of carbon dioxide is to Permeate Matrices, coadiuvating water’s solvent action. This system, experimented on green coffee, allowed its decaffeination and the total recovery of caffeine from the separators.

These new generation systems are different from traditional one. They need two high pressure pumps working at the same pressure, one for CO2 the other for H2O.

Among several supercritical fluids carbon dioxide is usually promoted as a green solvent. Supercritical fluid extraction of ethanol from the aqueous solutions produced in biochemical processes has several advantages over conventional separation methods; over the years there have been many reports on the separation process using CO2 and/or the required phase equilibria data for the carbon dioxide + water + ethanol system at elevated pressures.

Supercritical CO2 has been also used to extract components from hydro-alcoholic mixtures. On the other hand, ethanol aqueous solutions are used as solvents of different substrates in particle design using supercritical CO2.

Mixtures of carbon dioxide and ethanol + water at 308.15 K show an increasingly exothermic behavior when the pressure is lowered from 8.5 to 7.5 MPa.

High pressure extractions of polar compounds using supercritical CO2 followed by Enhanced Solvent Extraction (ESE) with diverse CO2/ethanol/H2O solvent mixtures (0–90%, 0.5–100%, 0–95%, v/v/v), at 313 K and 21 MPa, shows that this ESE solvent mixtures has a substantial effect on extracts yield and composition.

With step sequential extraction, CO2 only followed by CO2 + EtOH and finally CO2 + H2O shows different kind of fractionated extracts. Removing fat before performing CO2 + EtOH +H2O, the process gives improved results.

Propriété du CO2 supercritique

Propriété du CO2 supercritique

ADVANTAGES USING  CO2  IN SUPERCRITICAL STATE

Characteristics of supercritical 
CO2 state
Benefits derived by the supercritical CO2 
specific characteristics

is odorless, non-toxic

does not contaminate raw material or the  environment

is a gas in the atmosphere. Biological  processes leave no trace or contamination

allows utilization of waste products as raw materials or other byproducts

critical temperature of  the process is near  to the room temperature

ability to obtain extracts without thermic alteration

retains its high permeability similar to a gas

the extraction time is shorter than that required by common solvent extraction

changing conditions of pressure and temperature also can change the solvent properties

efficient extraction and high product quality

is inexpensive, does not burn, does not present the risks associated with the use of organic solvents

easy to use and safe

CO2 industrial recycling is simple and thermodynamically neutral

cost savings for energy and solvent

CO2 is taken from the atmosphere and returns to the atmosphere

CO2  extraction cycles applied  to industrial process do not alter the environmental balance

completely saturates the extraction chamber

removal of the extract from the matrix is complete, occurs in a single industrial phase and it is not subject to very rapid heating as in other technologies. Optimization of processing times. Inhibition of oxidative processes.

the high pressure process generates  differential pressure between the inside and the outside of the cells of bacteria and microorganisms

in many cases remarkable or total reduction of bacteria is obtained

high flexibility. Use in many different operating conditions in industrial processes

use in extraction, fractionation,  polymerization and micronization, pasteurization, purification, synthesis reactions, etc..

The molecule of CO2 is not polar

He has a remarkable facility to dissolve the fat fraction like vegetable oils and waxes

Can be used as a carrier for its permeability to matter

Associated with water as a solvent also can extract hydrophilic substances with remarkable efficiency (such as caffeine from coffee)

Supercritical Fluid Fractionation (SFF)

Fractionnement en fluide supercritique (FFS).

For Fractionation it is meant the separation of one or more components (from a mixture) with the employment of a miscible or immiscible solvent, thanks to a favorable repartition coefficient of the solute. The repartition coefficient is given by the ratio between the solute concentration in the SCF at the equilibrium and the concentration of the solute in the starting matrix at the equilibrium.The extraction is a convenient process only if the component to extract shows simultaneously:

  • A favorable repartition coefficient (meaning a high solubility in the SCF);
  • A favorable separation factor (if evaluated in relation to possible compounds being extracted from the mixture together with the compound of interest).

In the other cases, in order to obtain a satisfactory separation level, it is necessary to recur to the fractionation process, modifying the Fractionation Tower (or Column) configuration (see figure): the column is divided in a Rectification Section (the portion of the column above the feeding section) and an Exhaustion Section (the portion under the feeding section). The fractionation can occur in two different ways: by temperature gradient and by extract reflux. The choice of one of the two methods is generally conditioned by the plant design.

If the tower is equipped with a heating system differentiated along the column height, it is convenient to realize the temperature gradient fractionation with the tower heated at different temperatures, generally increasing along the height. The different compounds’ solubility in SC-CO2 decreases, most of the times, with the temperature increase. In the exhaustion section, where the temperature is lower, there will be a rough but efficient solubilization of the compounds to fractionate. In the rectification section instead, temperature is set properly in order to provoke a drastic decrease in the solubility of one of the two compounds. This will be released by the SC-CO2 and it will undergo an internal reflux, while the most soluble compound will be concentrating in the extract. This kind of fractionation allows to modulate the selectivity factor (within certain limits) modifying the temperature in relation to the exhaustion section.

Anyway it is necessary to know in advance the solubility of the compounds to separate in SC-CO2 in relation to the temperature. The reflux fractionation of the extracts occurs at constant temperature, but it needs the insertion of a second pump for the liquids before the separator, in order to recirculate part of the extracts toward the column head. In this way, therefore, even if the separation factor is not very favorable, it is possible to obtain the fractionation, since the mixture fed is more and more rich in the desired component. Regulating the extracts fraction to recycle and the number of recycles to apply, it is possible to obtain a total extract having the desired composition.In the case in which the separation factor is such to forbid separation with extraction mode or, instead, extract richer than the possible limit reachable are requested, it is necessary to apply reflux fractionation. In the case of SFF the extracting phase is constituted by SC-CO2, which might be added of a co-solvent.

Fractionation principles of ethylesters in tower.

  • Let’s suppose, for simplicity reasons, that the ethylesters mixtures are composed by two pseudocomponents, meaning groups of molecules with similar behavior:
  • Light ethylesters, being 14-18 C fatty acids;
  • Heavy ethylesters, being 20-22 C fatty acids.

Since the first group of compounds is more soluble in SC-CO2, it derives that an increase in the concentration of a heavy ethylesters mixture, it means to remove in the most efficient way the light ethylesters. Such removal can be conveniently performed utilizing Filling Towers, in which a solvent phase and a liquid phase (ethylesters mixture) come in touch countercurrent. The filling tower is the equipment usually utilized for liquid mixtures fractionation with liquid or gaseous solvents. The name tower (or column) comes from the fact that it appears to be like a recipient having a high height-diameter ratio. In general the fractionation is performed feeding continuously and countercurrent the mixture to separate and the extraction solvent. In order to maximize the contact between the phases and the mass exchange, inside the tower there is the filling, made of elements having proper size and/or shape (non structured filling ).

When the filling tower is at regime, the liquid mixture to fractionate, fed at the top of the tower, Moves Down along the filling delivering the most soluble compounds to the extraction solvent, which is lighter and moves along the tower in the opposite direction. The exhausted fraction (refined) is collected from the bottom of the tower, and the extract (composed by the solvent and the solubilized products) is collected from the top. In other words, in the case of ethylesters mixtures the lighter fraction of the mixture will be collected as extract at the top of the tower (being more soluble in the supercritical phase), while the heavier fraction (less soluble) will be collected from the bottom as refined, since it will concentrate in the residual liquid phase as an effect of the light fraction removal. Therefore it is to be considered that the more the similarity between the compounds to separate, the lower will be the productive capacity of the plant (expressed as Kg fractionate/column section), and the higher will be the height of the tower needed for the requested separation.

Qu'est-ce qu'un fluide supercritique?

Qu'est-ce qu'un fluide supercritique?

A supercritical fluid is any substance at temperature and pressure above its critical point. It can diffuse through solids like a gas, and it can dissolve materials like a liquid. In addition, close to the critical point, small changes in pressure or temperature result in

Large Changes in Density, allowing many properties of a supercritical fluid to be “fine-tuned”. Supercritical fluids are suitable as a substitute for organic solvents in a range of industrial and laboratory processes. Carbon dioxide and water are the most commonly used supercritical fluids, being used for decaffeination and power generation, respectively.

Supercritical Fluid Extraction (SFE) is the process of separating one component (the extractant) from another (the matrix) using supercritical fluids as the extracting solvent. If you need additional information, click here. Extraction is usually from a solid matrix, but can also be from liquids. SFE can be used as a sample preparation step for analytical purposes, or on a larger scale to either strip unwanted material from a product (e.g. decaffeination) or collect a desired product (e.g. essential oils). Carbon dioxide (CO2) is the Most Used supercritical fluid, sometimes modified by co-solvents such as ethanol or methanol. Extraction conditions for supercritical CO2 are above the critical temperature of 31°C and critical pressure of 74 bar. Addition of modifiers may slightly alter this. The discussion below will mainly refer to extraction with CO2, except where specified.

The Critical Point (C) is marked at the end of the gas-liquid equilibrium curve, and the shaded area indicates the supercritical fluid region. It can be shown that by using a combination of isobaric changes in temperature with isothermal changes in pressure, it is possible to convert a pure component from a liquid to a gas (and vice versa) via the supercritical region without incurring a phase transition.

The behavior of a fluid in the supercritical state can be described as that of a very mobile liquid. The solubility behavior approaches that of the liquid phase while penetration into a solid matrix is facilitated by the gas-like transport properties. As a consequence, the rates of extraction and phase separation can be significantly faster than for conventional extraction processes. Furthermore, the extraction conditions can be controlled to effect a selected separation. Supercritical fluid extraction is known to be dependent on the density of the fluid that in turn can be manipulated through control of the system pressure and temperature. The dissolving power of a SCF increases with isothermal increase in density or an Isopycnic (constant density) increase in temperature. In practical terms this means that a SCF can be used to extract a solute from a feed matrix as in conventional liquid extraction. However, unlike conventional extraction, once the conditions are returned to ambient the quantity of residual solvent in the extracted material is negligible.

The basic principle of SCF extraction is that the solubility of a given compound (solute) in a solvent varies with both temperature and pressure. At ambient conditions (25°C and 1 bar) the solubility of a solute in a gas is usually related directly to the vapor pressure of the solute and is generally negligible. In a SCF, however, solute solubilities of up to 10 orders of magnitude greater than those predicted by ideal gas law behavior have been reported.

The dissolution of solutes in supercritical fluids results from a combination of vapor pressure and solute-solvent interaction effects. The impact of this is that the solubility of a solid solute in a supercritical fluid is not a simple function of pressure.

Although the solubility of volatile solids in SCF is higher than in an ideal gas, it is often desirable to increase the solubility further in order to reduce the solvent requirement for processing. The solubility of components in SCFs can be enhanced by the addition of a substance referred to as an entrainer, or co-solvent. The Volatility of this additional component is usually intermediate to that of the SCF and the solute. The addition of a co-solvent provides a further dimension to the range of solvent properties in a given system by influencing the chemical nature of the fluid.

Co-solvents also provide a mechanism by which the extraction selectivity can be manipulated. The commercial potential of a particular application of SCF technology can be significantly improved through the use of co-solvents. A factor that must be taken into consideration when using co-solvents, however, is that even the presence of small amounts of an additional component to a primary SCF can change the critical properties of the resulting mixture considerably.

CO2 phase diagram – States of matter

Diagramme de phase du CO2 - États de la matière.

CO2 isn’t a liquid at room pressure: it’s a gas.

In the picture here on the right, taken from The Engineering ToolBox, the equilibrium curve is the colored one between the triple point and the critical point.

The Triple Point is the only plot’s point in which there are at the same time solid, liquid and gasseous phase of the material. It’s characterized by particular condition of temperature and pression. The Critical Point is characterized by the disappearance of the difference between gaseous phase and liquid phase.

In condiction of temperature and pressure over the critical point, we talk about Supercritical Fluid. The CO2 is at the same time a liquid a gas during all of the plot’s points that shape the Equilibrium Curve.

Going over other thermodynamic and technical discussions, maintaining the CO2 always along this curve will save a lot of energy. Our system is designed to maintain this equilibrium in the Reservoir, one of the most important vessel in the system.

Without a good control of temperature and pressure at the reservoir’s level, you’ll never be able to have a stable flow in the system.

In our system it’s easy to set the pressure in the reservoir at the desired value. We suggest 48 bar. The system, thanks to the full automation control, will stabilize the pressure automatically.

Le CO2 est-il polaire ou non polaire?

Le CO2 est-il polaire ou non polaire?

The supercritical fluid commonly utilized is carbon dioxide (CO2). The state diagram of CO2 visualizes the various phases (solid, liquid, gas) depending on pressure and temperature. CO2, at 31,1°C and 73,8 bar, is in its supercritical state, in which there is no distinction between liquid and gaseous phases (as shown in the following picture).

Increasing the temperature and keeping the pressure constant (73,8 bar), CO2 remains in the supercritical state, and so happens when pressure is increased and temperature is constant (31,1°C): this individuates two rays – respectively parallel to the pressure and temperature axes – defining the zone in which CO2 is in the supercritical state; in particular, within this state, the possible combinations of pressure and temperature are shown to variate CO2 solubilizing properties.

The reasons for the choice of this supercritical solvent are of economic (CO2 is cheap), environmental (CO2 is not toxic, it does not harm the ozone layer, it does not pollute and it does not contaminate the extracts) and technical (CO2 critical conditions can be reached easily) concern. SC-CO2 assumes the characteristics of a non polar solvent and it is comparable to n-Hexane; it has the characteristic to solubilize compounds which are scarcely soluble in water due to their nature.

Systèmes d'extraction au CO2 supercritique

If essential oils are wanted, the presence of water in the matrix interferes negatively on the process, because it is extracted together with the oil, hence it is necessary to remove it in a second moment. In order to avoid this problem, vegetable matrices are usually dried before extraction, unless extracts containing also polar substances are wanted. In this case it is necessary to add other solvents (entrainers or co-solvents) directly to the matrix or to the CO2, like ethanol or water, able to extract those compounds.

CO2 is chemically inert, so isomerization, oxidation or components hydrolysis are avoided. The advantage of this technique is that at the end of the extraction, the solvent can be removed as a gas, offering the possibility to recover the extracted concentrated compounds. In the industrial processes, CO2 can be recycled minimizing its consume. This technique finds several applications such as oil extraction from seeds, caffeine extraction from coffee, nicotine extraction from tobacco, etc.; it is also very convenient at industrial level. The advantages in using supercritical CO2 are largely of a “health and safety” and environmental nature and relate to increased unease about the presence of organic solvent residues in material for human consumption. It has good solvent characteristics for non-polar and slightly polar solutes.

It has a convenient critical temperature (31ºC). This enables extractions to be carried out at comparatively low temperature (often as low as 40 or 50ºC), decreasing the risk of damage of thermolabile compounds.

Most of the volatile components, which tend to be lost in hydro-distillation, are present in the supercritical extracts. Partly because of this, extracts obtained in this way tend to have flavor and taste, which are well liked by tasty panels. Extraction of natural raw material with supercritical CO2, allows the obtaining of extracts which flavor and taste are perfectly respected and reproducible. The supercritical fluid ability to vaporize non-volatile components (at moderate temperatures) reduces the energy spent, when comparing to distillation. Once the pressure excess in the equipment prevents oxygen entry while extraction occurs, oxidation reactions don’t happen.

In chemistry, we often talk about chemicals and solvents in terms of their polarity. Some chemicals are highly polar (i.e. water) and some chemicals are highly non-polar (i.e. hexane). When describing how a particular solvent will dissolve a chemical – there is a rule of thumb that ‘like dissolves like’. Meaning, a non-polar solvent will dissolve a non-polar chemical. All fats and oils are non-polar, thus using a non-polar solvent is most appropriate.

Extraction par fluides supercritiques (EFS)

Extraction par fluides supercritiques (EFS)

SFE is an alternative compared to the classic separation systems like fractionated distillation, steam current distillation, solvent extraction or thermal desorption. SFE can be applied to systems on a different scale: from lab-scale, analytic (from few hundreds milligrams to few grams of sample) or preparative (few hundreds grams of sample), to the pilot scale (kilograms of matrix), up to the industrial scale treating tons of raw material (e.g. in the coffee decaffeination process).
SFE can substitute many traditional extraction processes from vegetable matrices for the obtainment of dry extracts or essential oils with specific characteristics. The extraction of substances from complex mixtures, in particular, can be made highly selective modifying properly the operational temperature and pressure conditions, in order to adapt them to the Solubility of the different components of interest. An example is the terpenes removal from the essential oils from citruses and other officinal plants, through which a mixture of aromatic components stable to light and temperature is obtained (generally monoterpenes are not, and sometimes they contribute in no way to the smell).

On the basis of such premises, SFE progressively imposed itself as one of the elective technologies for the treatment, with different goals, of several raw materials of alimentary, pharmaceutical and cosmetic interest (active principles extraction and officinal herbs components extraction). Although theoretically there are many supercritical fluids available for the purpose, CO2 is the Fittest. In fact it is non toxic, inert, non flammable, cheap, recyclable and environmentally harmless. CO2 extraction is a modern extraction technology for hydrophobic vegetable components realized according to a clean procedures without release of any residue nor solvent substances.
After the extraction the operation pressure is lowered and the CO2 loses its solvent power releasing the solute substances, which are available in a concentrated and pure form. For these reasons FDA marked this process as GRAS (Generally Recognized As Safe). Natural substances, moreover, usually are not very stable at high temperatures, and need to be kept at temperatures next to the environmental one: CO2’s critical temperature is 31°C, making of it particularly fit as solvent for biologic substances. Proteins, carbohydrates, inorganic salts or metals are not co-extracted in any way. CO2 extracts are microbiologically stable and do not need particular storage conditions, because given their nature they are practically sterile. Unlike conventional procedures, the Extraction Selectivity is Specific.
The method does not involve thermal stress and does not need organic solvents.